When Is Your Next Automation Audit?

Man looking frustrated while staring at his phone, wearing a leather jacket, seated indoors with a window in the background. Hand placed on his head, expressing confusion or exasperation.

This past week, I spent the afternoon with a group of energetic business owners. We worked together to design each company’s approach to customer service.

One of the reactions that resulted from our work was, as one participant put it, “I’m realizing I don’t know exactly what our clients are experiencing.”

I believe this is the case for many companies. Their customer experience process is often forgotten and abandoned, quietly resulting in the loss of loyalty, referrals and revenue.

How does customer service get ignored? And how can improvements be implemented?

Experience #1

In 2024, I paid invoices of approximately $13,000 to a company that moved my home heating away from oil. The process involved installing a 200 amp service, insulating my basement, running new wiring, removing the oil tank and radiators, and installing baseboard heaters and the heat pump.

The teams that showed up to do the work were amazing. They were friendly and kind, answered all my questions, and left their workspaces tidy. This was such a great experience that I freely recommended the company to friends and colleagues.

Then, on one of the coldest days this winter, the heat pump stopped working. I found the correct error message in the manual, directing me to call for service.

When I called, the auto-attendant told me I was the only caller waiting. There was an option to press 9 and have someone call me back. After about 16 minutes on hold, I chose to press 9. And … I never heard back.

I did get everything working by shutting off the heat pump on the electrical panel and then restarting it, but the same problem occurred a week later. When I called for service, the same thing happened – no response.

Being “The Phone Lady” – and generally pretty stubborn – I took a new approach. I researched the company’s head office, tracked down the name of the executive in charge of customer service and picked up the phone. The automated message did not provide an option for a receptionist or administration, so I chose accounts. (You know … follow the money!)

When I was told that the executive in charge of customer service could only be reached by email, I pushed back. My tone of voice indicated that email wasn’t going to work for me and that someone better speak to me immediately. (I rarely use this tone. It is far from pleasant.)

Fortunately, it worked. Someone did take my call; I recognized their name from my research of the company’s staff. When I shared my experience, the reaction was, “Oh, that’s an automated process. Our IT department handles that. It’s set up so that all the calls are returned.”

I repeated my experience and indicated that if it had happened to me, it was happening to other customers. The staff member said they would reach out to the IT department. (Since this conversation, I’ve received numerous emails from the company offering me a discount on any new work I may need. What I need is service!)

Needless to say, I’m moving on. No more referrals and definitely no new projects with this company. And, while the IT department can certainly set up automated processes, it seems irresponsible to me to put it in charge of the customer experience.

Experience #2

Much to my dismay, my dentist of 27 years retired in 2024. They were well-prepared, with new owners already in place before they left. January would be my first visit to the office with all the new staff in place.

On the day of my appointment, I woke up with a fever, cough, etc. Not a great way to visit the dental hygienist. I set about to contact the office as early in the morning as possible so they could offer the appointment to someone else.

Since they text me reminders, I texted them my news. I received a message saying, “Please do not reply. This is an automated texting service. Please call the office directly.”

I called the office. The recorded message offered options only for specific dentists. Nothing for an office manager or receptionist. Since I don’t yet know who my dentist will be and wanted to make sure they knew I wasn’t coming, I called twice and left messages in two different places. At 9:02 AM, I did receive a text from a new number, letting me know they’d received my message. There was no name attached to this text.

Compared to my 27 years of phoning my dentist, speaking to office manager Kathi, and experiencing a strong relationship with the entire team, it feels like this automated process pushes me away. There is no “welcome” and definitely no relationship.

I understand dental offices are busy places, and automation provides efficiencies. The question is, how do the clients receive it, and is it negatively impacting revenue?

It’s Time for an Audit

A simple solution is scheduling a quarterly audit of your automation. Don’t wait until a customer complains or leaves without saying why. Task a staff member to act like a customer for one day and report back on their experience. If this isn’t feasible, hire a customer service professional to do the audit and provide feedback.

How a customer experiences our companies is vital to our success, our ability to build strong relationships, receive referrals, and keep doing what we do best.

Inspire Conversation! If your customer service processes are up to speed, this article offers suggestions for auditing your sales processes.

Real-time conversation skills directly impact leadership effectiveness, customer experience, collaboration, and business growth.

As communication becomes increasingly digital, many professionals spend less time practicing and using the skills required for clear, confident and effective real-time conversations. Explore new options for improvement.

conversation-divide (2)

6 thoughts on “When Is Your Next Automation Audit?”

  1. Great article, our company lost a significant order due to a misunderstanding with an automated voice mail installation that was new to our company. The next week it was removed and we have since always answered the phone to provide human interaction.

    Reply
    • Thanks so much Scott, for sharing this experience and … it says a lot about your company that you solved the issue by answering the phone and creating conversation. Conversation is, truly, the best way to communicate. While we can still misunderstand each other during a real-time conversation, it also offers the best way to address misunderstandings and move forward with trust and a strengthened relationship.

      Reply
  2. Fantastic advice Mary Jane. So annoying when one can’t speak to a real person. I will say I am lucky that both my dentists use automated system reminders, etc but always answer the telephone!

    Reply
    • So glad that your dentist is using both systems. It makes a big difference in the efficiency of our communication. Thanks for your comment.

      Reply
  3. I’m noticing a disturbing trend… websites with NO contact info, link or form. I’m looking at moving a fair bit of business to a new provider and can’t talk to anyone. The AI chat is useless for answering my questions and won’t refer me to a real person unless I already have an account. Oh my, will we still be in business when this trend reverses?

    Reply
    • Linda … this sounds dreadful. They will only talk to you once you are a paying client? A suggestion … if possible find a way to leave a message for “sales”. When a company thinks there is money to be made, they often find time to talk to us.

      Reply

Leave a comment

To celebrate 20 years of The Phone Lady, we're revisiting what truly makes communication meaningful. Every second week, we'll share a bit of wisdom to remind us that small shifts in how we speak, listen, and connect make a big difference. (You'll also receive access to our Exclusive Resources, including 4 ebooks.)

Topics

What's The Phone Lady Doing These Days?

  • Delivering training to female founders on Validation and Sales + One-on-One Coaching
  • Ongoing one-on-one coaching with business owners
  • Working with The Sales Coaching Institute as the phone sales coach and trainer
  • Communication skills training for veterinary assistants and veterinary technicians with Nova Scotia SPCA College for Animal Welfare
  • Exploring B2B sales options for a national long distance mover
  • Delivering a communication workshop for Atlantic Canada's leading construction supply company
  • Preparing to launch a limited series podcast in January!

Do you or your team want to improve your communication skills? Do you have a communication question or challenge you'd like to discuss? This quick-to-fill-out form is easy to use. You'll hear from me very soon.